Teaching the Full Force of the Art of Argumentation: A Startling Claim by Apthonius

Jim Selby May 28, 2011

Presented at:
SCL Conference 2011


Apthonius makes a remarkable and initially puzzling claim that stages five and six, Refutation and Confirmation, of his Progymnasmata impart the full force of the art of invention (the first canon of classical rhetorical theory). This workshop offers a possible explanation by demonstrating how his curriculum trains the minds of our students to generate ideas or arguments on demand. We suggest that the first six stages of Aphthonius equip students with the Quality of Invention, the full force of the art, which later, formal instruction in Rhetoric will enhance with Quantity.


Argumentation Rhetoric Teaching


Jim Selby

Other Contributions by Jim Selby

Recommended Resources

Web Tools for Schools
Article by Mark Palmer in - SCL Conference 2014
Standards and Accountability for Christian Schools
Article by Timothy Wiens in - SCL Conference 2011
Common Core, AdvancED, and Changes in the Works
Article by David Goodwin in - SCL Conference 2015