Craig Hefner, Head of School, Covenant School, Huntington, West Virginia

June 12, 2026

As I reflect on the unique group of leaders and teachers who serve classical Christian schools, it occurs to me that people of this type would do well to return again and again to the primary source material for practical and often messy leadership in the context of God’s created world: the wisdom and theology of Proverbs.

How to Read Proverbs

Leaders of complex institutions are not surprised at all to find seemingly opposite commands right next to each other in this book:

Answer not a fool according to his folly,

lest you be like him yourself.

Answer a fool according to his folly,

lest he be wise in his own eyes. (Prov 26.4–5)

A literal reader might find this a paradox or a contradiction: Answer a fool or don’t answer the fool? Which is the command? But a leader of a classical Christian school will immediately understand. For in the real work of school leadership, we have encountered both fools that need to be answered and fools who should be ignored lest you become like them. And, if we’re honest, we’ve all even been the fool who should either be ignored or answered.

These tensions can be resolved only with wisdom and prudence, and so Proverbs is a wonderful book for us. It is a book where we might find rest, encouragement, and theological wisdom in the complex tensions of leadership. And so I invite you in your daily leadership of complex institutions to draw attention to this quintessential biblical book on wise living and wise leading and see what it might say to us.

There are many inadequate and mistaken ways of reading Proverbs. The first – most tempting to school leaders – is to treat the book of Proverbs like a book of practical tips, advice, and best practices but with divine authority and guarantee – as if it is a book of leadership best practices but with God’s direct approval. The second, and opposite way, is to read it as a law-oriented book, a book of strict dos and don’ts.

Instead, the book of Proverbs is clearly an invitation to its hearers to develop character and discernment to know what is the wise choice in a complex situation. The basis for this wisdom is found in wisely living and acting within the context of God’s created cosmos and the patterns we see there.

This vision of wise leadership rooted in a deep understanding of God’s created cosmos is an expansive topic. But I want to focus specifically at the very center of this book, and what it puts forward as the theological grounding to the entire book: “The fear of the Lord is the beginning of wisdom.” (Prov 1.7)

What is the “Fear of the Lord”?

The fear of the Lord is the beginning of wisdom is the theological grounding to all practical wisdom of the book, but what does this phrase mean? I will admit that for a long time this phrase meant very little to me. The phrase has an abstract quality and sentimentalism. But on further contemplation, it is clear that it is a profound phrase with serious implications for our life and leadership. Indeed, ‘fear’ is not the kind of literal fear or terror that would create a further distance from the Lord. Rather, the ‘fear of the Lord’ is, as many commentators have noted, an Old Testament synonym for what the New Testament would simply call faith. The fear of the Lord is, in other words, a posture of receiving the truth of God’s cosmos as it is made and revealed by him. As an example, we see this close identification of ‘fear of the Lord’ and faith in the New Testament book of James, where James nearly identifies wisdom and faith with one another (James 1.5–8).

This ‘faith’ is made even more particular when we recognize that the “LORD” is not a reference to a generic belief in God. It is the divine name, YHWH, by which God revealed himself as both creator and redeemer to Israel. That is to say, the name “LORD” in Prov 1.7 specifically recalls the name of the God who brought Israel out of Egypt and made Israel a people among the nations.

We know that we need wisdom to lead schools well and to be the kind of people God calls us to be. As we look to apply this to our present life and leadership of schools, we must recognize that the beginning of wisdom is, in fact, faith – not a generic faith in a generic ‘theistic god’ but faith in God the creator and God the redeemer in Christ.

The Either/Or of Proverbs

In this bedrock claim of Proverbs, we find a refreshingly clear either/or, a definitive choice we must make. In the often gray and ambiguous space of leadership, we grow accustomed to pragmatic choice, offsetting interests, and compromises. But in Proverbs we find a sharp decision, a line in the sand. Prov 1.7 asserts that wisdom begins in the fear of the Lord, and in the next line states the opposite choice: “Fools despise wisdom and instruction.”

And indeed, we find that the entire book continues with this absolute sharp contrast: You either find wisdom or you are a fool. There are according to Proverbs only two ways, one that leads to life and the other that leads to death.

Beginning Leadership in Faith

All of us desire this kind of wisdom. We seek that perfect combination of theoretical and practical applied skill that leads to a flourishing life. Proverbs 1.7 puts us on the first step down this path. We must begin with faith in God the creator and redeemer. So, what does it look like to begin leadership and life from this kind of theologically grounded wisdom?

It is important here to note the different ends for the fool and the wise. According to Proverbs, the fool’s end is death, but the wise one’s end is rest. The end for the wise one is not then success at getting things done quickly, but rest.

Leading from Rest

This has a direct implication for our life and leadership of our school. If we begin with faith, we can lead and live unburdened and out of rest because the whole thing, the whole endeavor of our lives and our schools, begins in and is grounded in God’s promises. The wise leader then is one who sleeps. The fool consumed by worry does not. The wise leader can lose a decision, a vote, lose a donor, even a position, and still rest because their life is not grounded in outcomes but faith in the Lord.

Beginning wise leadership with faith gives you the right view on the institutions we serve. If you begin with the perspective of faith, you begin from the standpoint that your institution is not your own, it belongs to the Lord, not to you.

We need desperately to see that, to step back and hear the story of what our schools and communities are and how God is working through it. As the agent in the middle of it, we often lack the perspective to see this. In the midst of the hard work of leading a school, it seems like the work of our own hands. Proverbs remind us to see the whole thing from a further distance and only from there you can see that God is at work in your life and in your community.

Beginning wise leadership with faith also gives us the right view on ourselves as individuals. We begin the work of wisdom of leading and operating schools in faith, that you are created and redeemed by Christ. As leaders of schools, it is easy to slip into the false belief that we are loved and valued for what we do, for what we get done. But there is freedom in knowing that we begin all our work with the knowledge that we are created by God and that we are redeemed in Christ before and without regard to how we lead our school. We can fail spectacularly, and it will still always be true that you are loved by God in Christ because we begin our work in faith.

The book of Proverbs invites all of us instead to begin all our work and leadership in faith. When we begin in faith, we find wisdom and we enjoy a kind of rest that can ground and sustain us.

About Craig Hefner: Dr. Craig Hefner serves as Head of School at Covenant School in Huntington, West Virginia. He holds a Ph.D. in Systematic Theology from Wheaton College, an M.Div. from Trinity Evangelical Divinity School, and a B.A. in Pre-Seminary Studies with a minor in Greek from Cedarville University. At Covenant School he oversees the school’s academic, advancement, and operational efforts and serves as an ex-officio member of the school’s Board of Directors. Before joining Covenant School, Dr. Hefner taught at the collegiate level and held leadership roles in both church and campus ministries. Additionally, Craig serves on the board of the Society for Classical Learning. Dr. Hefner and his wife, Rachel, have three children and are active members of the Church of the Resurrection.