Eric Cook

For years now I have been promoting Governance as Leadership, an excellent book on governance, that I believe every board and head should read. The book lays out three modes of governance: fiduciary, strategic, and generative. The fiduciary mode focuses on compliance and stewardship. It is an important, necessary function of the board, but the lowest level of board leadership.

The second mode is the strategic. When boards are in strategic mode, they consider ways in which the organization can improve. They often develop a guiding document around strategic priorities and goals. Chait, one of the authors, argues that the strategic mode is important for boards, but is not sufficient for strong governance. The way boards excel is through being adept at the generative mode of governance.

The fiduciary and strategic modes are familiar to boards, but are not the means of adding the greatest value. If fiduciary work is all boards do, it is essentially the equivalent of a substitute teacher. The focus becomes keeping things in the fence, but not advancing towards an aspirational end. One reason why Chait says that boards tend to default almost exclusively to the fiduciary and strategic modes of governance is because they are often unclear about what their role is altogether.

Chait’s research shows that board members consistently report they are not fulfilled in their roles, often because they don’t know what they are even supposed to be doing. Board members exert a lot of time and energy, but often reactively and with minimal effectiveness. Learning the generative mode can change that and allow boards to maximize the talent, expertise, and wisdom of the leaders they have assembled to govern.

The generative mode is the strongest source of leadership for the organization, and its primary role is “sense maker.” The board “decides what to decide,” discerns challenges and opportunities, and probes assumptions. It examines the presuppositions behind the strategies and frames issues around the school’s values and mission. The fiduciary and strategic modes are important, but not complete. They leave out expressive aspects of the organization, which needs clarity around the right principles, values, and insights. Generative governance ensures the problems are understood in view of the school’s identity and core values. It provides the head with the board’s collective “mind” around the most important issues the school is facing.

As Chait says, “Before they use various forms of managerial expertise to solve problems, organizations need to figure out which problems need solving. Before they figure out the best strategy for getting from the present to a preferred future, organizations need to figure out what that preferred future is.” The generative mode forces boards to ask “why” before they get to how; to know the right problems to solve, and what will frame the solutions they seek.

As an example, take financial aid. Let’s suppose a board is dissatisfied with the current system and wants to explore a better solution. A fiduciary approach will focus on cost, compliance, and process. The strategic mode will focus on the strengths and weaknesses of the new system, how to implement and communicate any changes, and how it impacts the systems in place. It may also look at comparative analysis of various financial aid systems.

The generative mode calls for first asking, why do we have financial aid? What is the desired demographic of our student body/families? How does financial aid represent our mission/values as an organization? What principles should guide our process? This is so important because “the framework within which issues will be viewed and decided is often tantamount to determining the result.” Understanding a clear why will yield the kind of clarity needed to approximate the right solution. Generative thinking should precede the fiduciary and strategic problems. It should undergird the how and the what of the board’s activity and problem solving.

Generative governance makes governance indispensable, making the best use of the insights and abilities of the board. It is most helpful to the head of school and deeply satisfying for trustees. Generative thinking demands a fusion of thinking, not a division of labor; it places high value on deliberation, facilitation, and trust; and, it almost guarantees that boards are not meddling in operations.

To do generative governance well will mean less formality in meeting structure (note: Robert’s Rules of Order is a terrible paradigm for generative discussion); more open ended conversation, and a mindset that allows for healthy disagreement. Generative governance requires patience and great facilitation skills from the chair. It requires a “new approach to trustee recruitment, one that stresses quality of mind, a tolerance for ambiguity, an appetite for organizational puzzles, a fondness for robust discourse, and a commitment to team play.”

For most boards, a steep learning curve exists for governing in the generative mode. That is to be expected. It challenges many non-profit norms and implicitly pushes boards to reexamine many of their practices and even their current composition. Chait offers a helpful way to improve by suggesting boards should profile and recruit board members based on the three modes of governance. How many generative thinking board members do you have? Examine the people and practices of your board to determine if your vision for governance is generative. The effectiveness of your board and the engagement of your board members will improve dramatically. But, more importantly, the families and students you are there to serve will be the recipients of wise and focused leadership.

10 Ways Your Board Can be More Generative

In the last two entries I made the case that boards need to be more generative. Generative governance is focused on sense making, framing the work of the organization around essential questions of the school’s mission and values. This type of governance helps boards do the three things it must do well: identify the most important issues, engage in thoughtful deliberation about those issues, and then make sound decisions to ensure meaningful results.

The problem largely emanates from identifying the critical issues. If boards latch on to peripheral (operational) issues, the opportunity cost is significant. Boards do not meet that often and the time is limited. Generative governance is not merely about talking about key questions, it is about changing the mindset of trustees. In the boardroom, they are not executives nor are they employees of the school. They are trustees. It is easy to miss this, which is why Chait spends so much time on the “problem of purpose.” Being very clear about the board’s purpose will form the structure, form, and content of the board’s time. This is what generative governance is really about.

Generative governance is so important because:

  • It is how a board can add the greatest value to an organization; indeed, generative governance is most valuable because it is work only the board can do.
  • It is more engaging and intellectually challenging to trustees than traditional modes and models of governance
  • Generative governance is the best use of the board’s time and talent. Spending hours reporting and updating, meandering in operational matters is frustrating, wasteful, and boring.
  • Generative governance provides the head of school with the collective mind of the board without inserting itself into operations. Chait says, “Generative work conveys the gift of helping executives see things better, improving their perception and perspective so that they are in a better position to invent new goals, to discard old goals, to better see problems and to discard problems that really are not that important in the long run.”
  • Generative governance is less dependent on technical knowledge and allows board members to contribute without extensive educational expertise
  • It focuses the board’s time on clearly defining who the school is with respect to the most critical issues the school is facing. In this sense, it is enacting the board’s primary role as mission guardians and trustees of the school’s integrity and future.

If the reasons for becoming a more generative board are compelling, it may not yet be clear as to how a board would start being more generative. Here are 10 things your board can do to get started:

1. Brainstorm the essential questions of your school.

Ask your head (who should be adept at generative thinking!) and his executive team to generate a list of questions they see as crucial to the school. Use that as a baseline for the board to dig in, edit, modify, and add to the list. Here are some examples of topics and questions:

School Culture “” What are the distinctives of a classical, Christian school culture? How are those distinctives uniquely and particularly expressed at our school? What would it look like if our school culture was thriving?

Thick Christian Institution “” What is the ideal vision for a thick Christian institution/school? What should be the feel and ethos of a thick Christian school? What beliefs and practices would characterize a thick Christian school? What are the essential external/cultural/community commitments of a thick Christian school?

2. Meet outside the boardroom.

When your board meets in a more casual setting the conversation will naturally be more creative and generative. Boards tend to be locked into tight structures that actually stifle rather than stimulate good conversation. Put the agenda aside, serve some good food and wine, take the questions mentioned above and facilitate a great dialogue. Classical Christian school boards should be good at this! Give it a go. As a side benefit, BoardSource reports that boards that meet outside the boardroom have significantly higher trust levels than boards who do not.

3. Assign your more generative thinking board members to facilitate conversation.

Your visionaries, if you have them on your board, will be the ones most excited about this move to more generative thinking. Allow them to use their expertise. Have them take time to frame the questions and facilitate the conversation when it is time to do so.

4. Educate your board about generative governance.

Assign your Governance Committee Chair and/or head of school to present to the board what generative governance is and why it is important. Read Governance as Leadership as a board and make it part of your onboarding process. Look for generative board members, not just fiduciary members.

5. Schedule time in your agenda reserved for generative conversations.

If you do not schedule the time, it will likely not happen. Frontload the questions ahead of time so everyone can be thinking about them. If you need to, end the official meeting time and then begin the generative portion. This will allow everyone to relax, speak freely, and shed the Robert’s Rules of Order mentality.

6. Take 2-3 items on your strategic plan and analyze the degree to which you are approaching them generatively.

Look at your strategic plan. Have you identified the most important questions and issues for each initiative? Are you more focused on how than why?

7. Silent starts.

Begin your generative discussion time with a few minutes for each board member to write on an index card the most critical question relevant to the issue at hand. At the end of discussions give each board member five minutes to write down any thoughts or questions that were not expressed.

8. Reflect on the school’s history and growth through a generative lens.

Boards are composed of smart people. They are problem solvers and doers. They know how systems work and want to bring resolution to issues. However, be careful you are not rushing to solutions when the problems are not understood in light of the essential questions. The board’s competencies and confidence can be an obstacle if there is not humility, patience, and a willingness to go deeper.

9. Arm your board with a bank of generative questions

Here are some questions that Chait and others suggest: What three adjectives or short phrases best characterize your school? What will be most strikingly different about this school in five years? What do you hope will be most strikingly different about this school in five years? On that list, which would you rank at the top? Five years from now, what will this school community think was the most important legacy of this board? What will be different about this board and how it governs ten years from now? How would we respond if a donor offered us $2,000,000 tomorrow? What has a competitor done successfully that we would not choose to do as a matter of principle? What headline about our school would we most want to see at the end of this school year? Where is the grossest discrepancy between what we say we do and what we actually do?

10. Conduct case studies and simulations.

Considering scenarios that the board has not yet confronted allows you to get a feel for navigating ambiguous situations with generative thinking at the forefront. For example, smaller schools often form stewardship policies in real time as issues arise rather than preemptively. This is risky because you don’t want your naming policy to be formed around a particular donor and dollar amount. You want to form your policies on principle and values that are forged out of healthy deliberation, not with whether your gym will be built or not.

All of these recommendations are simple to implement. Take some time with your board chair and discuss ways in which you can move towards a more generative governance model.

Works Cited

Chait, Richard P., William P. Ryan, and Barbara E. Taylor. Governance as Leadership: Reframing the Work of Nonprofit Boards. Wiley, 2005.