By Troy Schuknecht
In a recent parent survey at Covenant Classical School, parents requested ninety-three new offerings. These are well-meaning parents asking for good things—and asking someone who loves to see their faces light up when I say “yes.” In the words of Tommy Boy’s father, Big Tom Callahan, “Why say no, when it feels so good to say yes?”
Nearly every school begins with a robust, compelling mission statement and a palpable energy driving them in a unified direction. Tragically, over the years—one small drift at a time—the founding missions of many schools become fuzzy at best, or worse, unrecognizable. How does this happen? Our schools drift in the same way individual people do; it is not one massive decision that changes everything, but one small concession after another. Let me be so bold as to illustrate this using a book that is anathema to most classical educators.
Though the first three Hunger Games books are largely brain candy, the fourth is compelling. It is a prequel that highlights the transformation of young and seemingly virtuous Coriolanus into President Snow, the chief and hated villain of the initial trilogy. Even though the reader knows how it is going to end, one grows to love and respect Coriolanus. At the end of the book, when he finds himself doing the unimaginable, even he seems surprised by who he has become. His transformation is not sudden, but the compounding effect of a long series of understandable concessions.
Schools drift from mission in the same way. It is rarely the sudden hire of a leader who is completely misaligned with the mission. Instead, drift arises slowly—through well-meaning boards working alongside leaders who love the mission yet become distracted by too many good things. The chief cause of mission drift is the over-programming of our schools. We say yes to too many good things and lose the simplicity and focus required to pursue the most important things.
What is most important can be summarized by the definition of classical Christian education put forth by the Society for Classical Learning. We aim to “cultivate virtue and wisdom in students so that they will live for the glory of God, flourishing as human beings and loving both God and neighbor. It pursues these goals through an ordered exploration of the True, the Good, and the Beautiful that is grounded in the liberal arts tradition and that forms students’ affections and the habits of lifelong learning.”
The aim of education used to be much more simple and focused. In 1916, Sir Richard Livingstone wrote A Defense of Classical Education because he was concerned about the number of secondary schools adding science education. He valued science education at the university level, but he did not favor premature instruction in these subjects. Though I assume most readers of this article join me in disagreeing with Livingstone about the proper timing for science education, there is a valuable principle regarding the scope of offerings at our schools that is worthy of consideration. Livingstone put it this way:
“Some of our critics speak as if a boy came into a schoolmaster’s hands as steel comes into the hands of a machine-tool maker, ready, without further preparation, to be manufactured, and then let loose complete on the world. They forget that a boy of fourteen is raw material, and must undergo many processes before he is fit to take his final shape. No one would propose to make high pressure steel out of the crude ore as it leaves the mine; if he got any resulting metal from such an attempt, it would be course and brittle. But an attempt to run human raw material into its final mould before it has been refined and tempered will produce something equally unserviceable.”
Every student in your care is in the process of becoming. They are being formed. Nothing your school does is worth doing unless it clearly enhances this process of formation. When considering the adoption of any new program, we must go beyond determining whether it is merely good. Of the ninety-three items requested by the parents at Covenant Classical School, nearly all were good ideas that would be demonstrably beneficial to students. Yet the addition of any one of them—let alone all ninety-three—would impact our success in what is most important.
Before adding a new program, consider not just whether it is a good thing, but carefully evaluate the impact of each addition on your ability to execute your core mission. In the novel The Rector of Justin, Dr. Prescott said, “If a headmaster’s vocabulary were limited to a single word, he might still get by with ‘no.’” Steve Jobs observed that “true innovation is saying no to a thousand things.” By saying no to the good things, we say a resounding yes to the essential things. Our schools need to do less—and do it better.

About Troy Schuknecht
Troy Schuknecht is the Head of School at Covenant Classical School in Fort Worth, TX. He earned a Bachelor’s degree in Biology from Whitworth College and a Master’s of Divinity in Christian Ministry from the Southern Baptist Theological Seminary. He taught upper school science from 2003-2008 and has been serving in classical Christian school administration since 2008. He has been married to Stevi since 2003 and has four children.




