by Eric Cook

This article was written in response to a previous article, “The Ideal Education Requires ‘Some Small Place.‘”

“The best education is possible only at some small place.” The thesis and conclusion of the article is very compelling. The relationship between teacher and student is central to human formation and thus to education. So, beyond a certain size (student-teacher ratio), relational dynamics are made more difficult and the conditions for deep formation are compromised. There are natural limitations to the relational capacity of any person. This is what is known as Dunbar’s Rule. The idea is that there is a cognitive limit to the number of stable, meaningful relationships a human being can maintain at one time.

The reason that smaller educational settings afford deeper learning and formation are not merely practical, or simply pedagogical preference. This reflects a metaphysical truth at the center of reality. God Himself is a community of persons and love is the essence of His being. Out of that love God created the universe, but particularly man, setting the conditions for His love to be shared, emulated, and enjoyed.

This ought to both affirm and challenge the conclusions of the article. While I agree with the central idea, that the best education will happen in a small place, there is another abiding truth at the heart of the thesis. Love, fully realized, cannot remain contained, it presses outward to bless. It is the nature of love to overflow to others.

The professor in the article, at one point, acknowledges that the sheer volume of students to be taught often obstructs the ideal. I would take this one step further. While we want the ideal (small) in order to realize the deepest formation, we know that there is real tension in the desire to extend that good to others. The cynical read on growth would merely indict those who seek to extend it to others as just trying to impose inhumane market tactics and logic. Often, however, the motivations for growing are good, out of love, but there are other complexities in view, some moral, some strategic, and some relational. Getting the best education to all is a noble and worthy impulse, even if fraught with tension.

A host of challenging questions arise then. Is it more important to provide a less than ideal education (less relational depth and formation than the one-room schoolhouse, as the article implies), but to do so for more students? How do we grow schools that retain the highest commitment to the teacher-student relationship while making them more accessible to more families? Is it better to let schools grow “organically” or to intentionally replicate the ones who are the most capable at formation? What are the relational tradeoffs of very small schools versus the benefits that come from a well built institution? There are innumerable questions like this that do not have obvious answers.

At SCL, we have wrestled deeply with the first principles and philosophical tensions stated above. We have sought not only to account for these ideas, but design around the inherent limits rather than in defiance of them. We begin from the conviction that relationships are the primary constraint, not an obstacle to be overcome; that leadership and formation emerge non-linearly and cannot be forced without harm; that families are the core formative institution which schools must serve rather than replace; and that the most important goods (wisdom, virtue, love) can be recognized but not reduced to rubrics without distortion. Capital, in this view, is a servant rather than a driver, and donors remain morally implicated in judgment rather than outsourcing it. The aim is not to “scale” formation, but to cultivate it faithfully and make it accessible without destroying the conditions that allow it to exist at all.

The need and desire to expand and grow while retaining a thick relational grounding is not new. During the Reformation, the largest and most significant growth of classical Christian education in history, this was central to the vision. The Reformers were committed to grounding their work in the deep theological truths of the gospel. They highly valued the teacher-student relationship. However, they were unrelenting in their passion to grow more churches and schools to serve more and more families and students. Geneva Academy started their first day with 600 students. The Reformers believed that souls must be shepherded. There was no higher priority than ensuring there were capable schools and churches to do this work for as many students as they could serve!