Matt Skinner, Chief Financial Officer, SCL
May 28, 2026
Every board has experienced some version of this moment: a discussion about tuition begins and almost immediately the focus shifts to individual families. Someone asks whether a modest increase will cause a particular family to leave. Another raises concern about how many families might be affected more broadly. Someone else references what a nearby school charged last year. And before long, the conversation is no longer anchored in the school’s mission or long-term direction, but in a swirl of individual cases, perceived risks, and what feels reasonable in the moment. These instincts are not wrong. They reflect genuine care for families and a desire to steward relationships well. Tuition, however, is not fundamentally a family-by-family question. It is a strategic decision.
Tuition does far more than generate revenue. It shapes who a school is able to serve, and it determines whether the school can deliver on the promises it makes. When tuition is disconnected from strategy, schools begin to drift in predictable ways. Teachers are under-resourced, facilities are maintained reactively rather than proactively, and fundraising is required to cover core operations. Thriving schools approach tuition differently. They begin by defining who they are and where they are going. They clarify enrollment targets, class sizes, program expectations, compensation goals, and long-term aspirations. Only after those commitments are clearly established do they determine what tuition must be to support them.
Tuition often feels difficult because many schools do not have a clear understanding of what it actually costs to deliver the education they promise. This becomes visible when schools rely on hidden subsidies to close the gap. If annual fundraising is required to cover core salaries, tuition is being subsidized. If faculty compensation consistently falls short of what is required for the level of work expected, tuition is being subsidized. If maintenance is deferred year after year, or if leadership absorbs ongoing stress just to keep the model functioning, those are forms of subsidy as well. None of these costs disappear. They are simply shifted, often in ways that are not immediately visible.
Most leaders would say they want their school to be affordable. It is a well-intentioned desire, rooted in care for families and a genuine commitment to expanding access. But the concept itself often creates confusion rather than clarity. No school can be affordable for every family, and when schools attempt to be, they often become unclear about who they are actually serving. This is why thriving schools focus on accessibility rather than affordability. Affordability suggests a price that works universally. Accessibility asks a more honest question: how do we extend access intentionally and sustainably for the families we are called to serve?
This distinction reshapes how tuition and financial aid are understood. They are not separate strategies, but two parts of the same decision. When tuition is artificially lowered and aid is layered on top without clear purpose, schools undermine both sustainability and trust. By contrast, when tuition reflects the true cost of the program and aid is applied intentionally, schools are able to reach a wider and more diverse group of families. They are honest about cost and purposeful in their generosity. Accessibility, in this sense, is not about lowering standards or obscuring cost. It is about aligning generosity with purpose.
Tuition cannot be set responsibly in isolation. Yet many schools continue to treat it as an annual event, revisiting the same questions each year without anchoring them in a longer-term framework. This is why tuition conversations often feel repetitive and exhausting. Boards are not simply debating numbers. They are debating the future without having clearly defined it. Thriving schools approach this differently by defining the future first and then building a financial plan to support it.
A strategic financial plan is not merely a spreadsheet; it is the financial expression of a school’s intended future. It clarifies what the school is committing to deliver over time. It addresses questions about faculty culture, class size, facilities, and the level of financial stability required to move beyond survival. When these commitments are clearly named, tuition becomes one element within a coherent, multi-year model. The work shifts from annual negotiation to long-term stewardship and institutional clarity. Trade-offs are made intentionally, and decisions are grounded in shared clarity.
At the foundation of all of this is a concept that is often misunderstood in non-profit settings: margin. Many leaders assume that because a school is not-for-profit, it should not generate surplus. But non-profit is a tax designation, not a strategy. Without margin, schools operate in a perpetual state of pressure. Every challenge feels urgent, and every decision carries more weight than it should. Margin changes that dynamic by allowing schools to respond to challenges with intention rather than panic. It enables planned maintenance rather than deferred repairs. It creates stability during leadership transitions and flexibility when enrollment fluctuates. Reserves serve a similar purpose, as protection for continuity. They ensure that a single difficult year does not derail a long-term mission. Without margin and reserves, schools are always borrowing from somewhere, often from teachers through compensation pressure, from facilities through deferred maintenance, or from the future through exhausted leaders and eroded trust.
When all of these elements come together, a different kind of school emerges. It is a school that defines its future clearly, funds that future honestly, extends access intentionally, governs with courage, and plans with discipline. This is the goal of financial leadership: to protect the mission over time. Tuition, in that sense, is not merely a number on a pricing sheet. It is a declaration of institutional identity, the financial expression of what a school believes it is called to become.




